Todrick immediately found himself in a good position, being in both The Formation and Head of HouseholdMiesha Tate’s Athlete’s Alliance. Soon after however, he decided to give his complete loyalty to Miesha and began to target Carson Kressley. Despite being seen as a powerful duo, Miesha’s competition wins allowed them to evict anyone who opposedthem. In Week 3, Carson won HOH and Todrick knew that he and Miesha would be in danger. However, he was able to turn Carson and his partner Cynthia Bailey against loyal ally Shanna Moakler and target her instead. Todrick was able to get to Final 3 without being nominated and have both Cynthia and Miesha taking him to Final 2, with Miesha eventually doing so. Although he played a dominant game, it was greatly overshadowed by his poor treatment of the Jury, with him most notability telling Chris that his son would be disappointed in him and making derogatory comments about Shanna. Todrick’s jury management caused him to lose to Miesha in a 7-1 vote, only receiving Cynthia’s vote to win.
Todrick was offered a spot on Celebrity Big Brother 2 (US) and turned it down. This information was revealed by Perez Hilton who played on Celebrity Big Brother 15 (UK) and was also stated to be appearing on Celebrity Big Brother 2 (US) before being cut by production. He leaked this information in retaliation for being dropped.[1]
Following the finale of Big Brother 23 (US), Todrick threw a wrap party for the cast since CBS was not hosting one themselves due to the COVID-19 Pandemic. Todrick was a huge fan of The Cookout alliance, and so he allowed some of the houseguests from the season to stay at his house for a few weeks, even letting them house-sit while he was away. Many alumni came to the wrap party and meet the Cookout members afterwards, including two contestants from Big Brother Canada 9 and the experience was dubbed "BB23.5" on social media. Notably, Kyland Young would eventually move in with Todrick full-time and house-sat for him during CBB3, before Todrick ended up selling the house in May 2024.
Todrick was the last houseguest to be nominated on Celebrity Big Brother 3 (US), facing his first nomination by default on Day 29 after losing the Final HOH Competition.
Todrick, along with Carson Kressley are the third and fourth judges of RuPaul's Drag Race to appear on a Big Brother franchise. They were preceded by Michelle Visage and Ross Mathews.
