Big Brother Wiki

Natalie Starr Montgomery-Carroll was a houseguest on Big Brother 5 (US).

As a part of Project DNA, she switched places in the Big Brother House with her identical twin sister Adria Klein for the first four weeks, and because they pulled off their deception, Natalie was let into the house to play her own game. After Natalie and her sister turned on the Pinky Swear Alliance, both were nominated against each other. When Adria won the POV, Natalie's fate was sealed and she was evicted in a 4 to 1 vote, only receiving the vote of her sister, placing 8th and becoming the second member of the jury.


Natalie Carroll (born June 24, 1974) is a 30-year-old fitness professional from Birmingham, Alabama.

Player History - Big Brother 5 (US)[]

Competition History[]

Week 1 Not in House*
Week 2
Week 3
Week 4
Week 5 HOH Loss
Food Win
POV Not Chosen
Week 6 HOH Loss
Food Loss
POV Not Chosen
Luxury Loss
Week 7 HOH Loss
Food Win
Luxury Win
POV Loss
  • Although not officially playing as herself, Natalie played in multiple competitions before she officially entered the house.

Voting History[]

Week Position Voted For With Majority?
1 Not in House
5 Jase Wirey Yes
6 Will Wikle Yes
7 Nominated
Finale Jury Member Michael Ellis No

Post Big Brother[]



Big Brother 5 (US) Houseguests
Andrew Daniel2
Michael "Cowboy" Ellis
Diane Henry2
Jennifer "Nakomis" Dedmon
Karen Ganci
Marvin Latimer
Adria Klein
Small-Natalie Carroll
Will Wikle
Jason "Jase" Wirey
Scott Long
Holly King
Lori Valenti
Mike Lubinski