In Big Brother 5, Jase became the leader of the Four Horsemen alliance and quickly took the fall once the alliance imploded. Jase became a huge competition threat, winning 1 HoH and 2 PoVs during his stay in the house. He was evicted in Week 5 by a vote of 6-1, becoming the first victim of the now famous backdoor strategy. He placed 10th.
Jase returned for Big Brother All-Stars, after being selected by the public vote to enter the house. After winning the first HOH competition, he began to play both sides of the house, flip-flopping back on Chilltown and the Sovereign Six alliance. However, this came back to haunt him as he was nominated by James during Week 3 as a replacement nominee, which caused him to start trashing the backyard. After a plan to save him fell through, he was evicted in a unanimous 9-0 vote and placed 12th. He was accused of being part of the Mr. and Mrs. Smith alliance with his former rival, Diane. However, on finale night, this was confirmed as an alliance made before entering the house.